Want to change the feel of your mattress? A mattress topper is the best way to make your bed feel brand new! We tested and reviewed 32 of the best mattress toppers based on the following:
- Comfort
- Quality and safety of materials
- Versatility (thickness and density)
- Temperature regulation
- Ease of care and maintenance
- Price (including shipping, return policy, and warranty)
- User and expert reviews
Keep on reading to find the perfect upgrade for your mattress!
A QUICK LOOK AT THE 12 BEST-RATED MATTRESS TOPPERS
We may earn a commission from our affiliate partners if you buy products using links on this page. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure. 1. Puffy Mattress Topper
Best Overall Mattress Topper
- Secure fit on all mattresses
- Hypoallergenic + cool
- Two firmness options available
2. Lift by Amerisleep Mattress Topper
Best Mattress Topper for Hip Pain
- 2 versions (Comfort & Support)
- Cooling Celliant cover
- Made in the US
3. Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme
Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Best mattress topper for college students
- Cover is resistant to mold & allergens
- Multiple sales and discounts
4. Avocado Green Organic Latex Mattress Topper
Best Organic Mattress Topper
- Excellent quality of materials and craftsmanship
- Reinforced seams for a secure fit
- Zipper access around the bottom for easy access
5. Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Cooling Topper
Best Cooling Mattress Topper
- Made with bouncy foam for more coolness
- Made in the US
- Seasonal sales and discounts
6. airweave Top Mattress
Best Firm Mattress Topper
- Advanced Japanese technology
- Firm for extra support
- Ease of movement, no stuck feeling
7. Layla Memory Foam Topper
Best Soft Mattress Topper
- A cooler, cleaner, and more comfortable sleep
- Multiple sales and discounts
- Made in the US + 5-year warranty
8. PlushBeds Natural Latex Topper
Best Latex Mattress Topper
- Seasonal sales & discounts
- 20-year lifespan
- Hypoallergenic, antimicrobial, and dust-mite resistant
9. Parachute Down Mattress Topper
Best Down Mattress Topper
- Ethically and sustainably sourced
- Down alternative available
- Sales and bundle deals
10. Saatva Graphite Mattress Topper
Best Mattress Topper for Back Pain
- Available in three different materials
- Multiple sales and deals
- Best foam mattress topper with dual-layer design
11. Dreamfoam 2" Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Best Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Made in the US, 100% safe
- Flexible support + incredible comfort
- Best foam mattress topper for under $100
12. Zinus Swirl Gel Cooling Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Best Egg Crate Mattress Topper
- Ideal for shoppers on a budget
- Available in three firmness options
- Green tea for a relaxing smell
OUR MATTRESS TOPPER REVIEWS OF THE BEST ON THE MARKET
1. Puffy Mattress Topper
Best Overall Mattress Topper
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: 101 nights
- Warranty: Forever
- Shipping: Free
The Puffy Topper is a reliable and affordable solution guaranteed to suit all sleepers.
Let’s take a closer look at what makes the Puffy Topper one of the best memory foam mattress toppers available:
Materials
This is a hypoallergenic, 2-inch, responsive foam topper made of a 40% bamboo and 60% polyester blend. It has a soft and airy cover that’s removable and machine-washable for year-round freshness.
All materials are OEKO-TEX certified, meaning they’ve been tested and approved for safety and durability.
Feel
Available in two distinctive feels (made of different foam densities), this is the best mattress topper because it can add comfort or support, depending on your needs.
Cooling Features
The cushiony polyester and bamboo top provides coolness, while the breathable cover further increases airflow and prevents sleepers from overheating.
Compatibility
Thanks to the deep elastic pockets on the sides and the additional thin grip layer at the base, which eliminates movement, Puffy’s mattress topper can fit tightly on all beds up to 15 inches thick. These unique features ensure that it won’t shift or slide off the bed either.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 2 inches
- Certificates: Oeko-Tex certified materials
Pros
- + Secure fit on all mattresses
- + Hypoallergenic + cool
- + Two firmness options available
Cons
- − No returns before 30 days from purchase
2. Lift by Amerisleep Mattress Topper
Best Mattress Topper for Hip Pain
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 5 years
- Shipping: Free
Incorporating the incredible pressure-relieving HIVE technology with its targeted support for the most sensitive areas, the Lift can soothe pain-causing pressure points by 49%—making this one of the best mattress toppers for hip pain.
Materials
Made of 3 inches of high-quality memory foam, the Lift by Amerisleep is topped with an ultra-breathable cover that’s easily removed and washer-friendly.
The Comfort Lift uses Bio-Pur material for extra plushness, while the firmer model features the brand’s Affinity material for extra support.
All materials proudly carry the CertiPUR-US label for quality and safety.
Feel
The Amerisleep topper is available in two versions: the Comfort Lift (ideal for those looking for a softer feel and possibly the best mattress topper for side sleepers) and the Support Lift (designed for back and stomach sleepers).
Cooling Features
The Lift features an open-cell design to wick away heat, and it’s encased in an FDA-determined Celliant cover to boost circulation and help the body regulate temperature.
Compatibility
The bottom of the topper uses MicroGrip technology to secure it to your mattress without damaging the bed.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 3 inches
- Certificates: CertiPUR-US
Pros
- + 2 versions (Comfort & Support)
- + Cooling Celliant cover
- + Made in the US
Cons
- − A bit heavy to handle
3. Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme
Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: NA
- Warranty: 10 years
- Shipping: Free
What is the best memory foam mattress topper? With 25 years of experience and proprietary memory foam that’s denser and more durable than any other material on the market, the TEMPUR-Topper Supreme is the answer.
Materials
This fantastic mattress topper is covered in a knit polyester blend, which is not only resistant to mold, allergens, and dust mites but is also removable and washable. Under this moisture-wicking material, there are 3 inches of TEMPUR material—a unique fabric that adapts to the sleeper’s body for personalized support.
Feel
This patented foam mattress topper has a medium-firm feel, and with 3 inches of dense, slow-responsive memory foam, it gently conforms to the body, relieving pressure points at the same time.
Cooling Features
Besides being comfy, the TEMPUR foam is breathable and minimizes heat retention, so you won’t have to worry about hot nights even though you aren’t sleeping on memory foam.
Compatibility
The TEMPUR-Topper Supreme is compatible with all beds, but it’s so cozy and thick, you can use it on its own. It’s great for camping or RV-ing, a college dorm, or when you have guests over.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 3 inches
- Certificates: CertiPUR-US Certified
Pros
- + Best mattress topper for college students
- + Cover is resistant to mold & allergens
- + Multiple sales and discounts
Cons
- − No sleep trial for toppers
4. Avocado Green Organic Latex Mattress Topper
Best Organic Mattress Topper
- Type: Latex
- Trial period: 1-year
- Warranty: 10-year
- Shipping: Free
The Avocado Green Organic Latex Mattress Topper uses 100% certified organic materials for the most comfortable and luxurious sleep of your life.
Materials
This topper is made of GOLS certified organic latex, GOTS certified organic wool, and GOTS certified organic cotton, plus reinforced seams to hold it all together.
For eco-friendly shoppers, a vegan version is available with cotton fill instead of wool.
Feel
This natural latex mattress topper comes in two options: the Plush version (a 4 on the firmness scale, with 10 being firmest) and Firm option (around 7 out of 10), which uses medium-firm latex for gentle resilience and support.
Cooling Features
The ultra-soft organic wool quilted under the cotton cover is incredibly responsive, temperature-wise, allowing for natural air circulation and a refreshing and relaxing slumber.
Compatibility
Thanks to the cotton canvas bottom, the Avocado Organic Latex Mattress Topper will stay in place and fit any bed of your choosing.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 2.75 inches
- Certificates: GREENGUARD Gold Certified by UL Environment, GOTS Organic Certified by Control Union, MADE SAFE Certified, and OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified
Pros
- + Excellent quality of materials and craftsmanship
- + Reinforced seams for a secure fit
- + Zipper access around the bottom for easy access
Cons
- − Spot-cleaning only
5. Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Cooling Topper
Best Cooling Mattress Topper
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 2 years
- Shipping: Not free
If your mattress is too firm or too hot, our mattress topper reviews recommend trying Nest Bedding out.
Materials
The Alexander Signature Cooling Topper contains gel memory foam with premium pressure-relieving properties, topped off with an airy, synthetic blend cover. The foam is CertiPUR-US certified, so safety and durability are guaranteed.
Feel
This gel mattress topper is made with Nest Bedding’s Energex Foam, which gently cradles the body but doesn’t let sleepers sink into the material. It’s medium-soft—great for side and back sleepers who need cushioning in the hips and shoulders.
Sadly, it’s only available in a plush version, so if you’re looking to add firmness to your mattress, consider other options.
Cooling Features
The synthetic blend and the gel memory foam work together to wick away moisture and boost airflow. The Energex Foam, on the other hand, ensures that sleepers can easily move on the surface, stopping them from overheating and making this the best cooling gel mattress topper.
Compatibility
The Nest Bedding mattress upgrade has four straps in the corners, securing the topper and ensuring it doesn’t “run away” from the bed.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 2 inches
- Certificates: CertiPUR-US Certified and Love & Sleep Mattress’s Greenguard Gold Certification
Pros
- + Made with bouncy foam for more coolness
- + Made in the US
- + Seasonal sales and discounts
Cons
- − Only one firmness option available
6. airweave Top Mattress
Best Firm Mattress Topper
- Type: Fiber
- Trial period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 3 years
- Shipping: Free
Using innovative Japanese technology, this extra-firm mattress topper is the perfect addition for anyone looking for more support on their bed. The airweave Top Mattress is so effective that it can increase a bed’s firmness by 30% to 50%.
Materials
This topper’s cover is a polyester and cotton blend, while the core is made of 1.8 inches of proprietary eco-friendly, hypoallergenic, recyclable plastic airfiber. This patented fabric is incredibly durable, expanding your topper’s lifespan and justifying the higher price tag.
On top of that, it can be rinsed with water (while the cover can go in the washing machine), making this the only washable mattress topper in full.
Feel
The airweave Top Mattress is bouncy and responsive, offering resilient support across the entire surface and creating a floating feel.
Cooling Features
Airfiber isn’t just supportive; it provides temperature regulation, too. The combination of the interwoven airfiber core, which encourages airflow, and the breathable mesh cover go a long way toward producing cool and relaxing nights.
Compatibility
Versatile enough to accommodate most mattresses and sleep positions, the airweave topper is a great, supportive addition to any soft bed.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 2 inches
- Certificates: NA
Pros
- + Advanced Japanese technology
- + Firm for extra support
- + Ease of movement, no stuck feeling
Cons
- − Most expensive on our list of the best–rated mattress toppers
7. Layla Memory Foam Topper
Best Soft Mattress Topper
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: 120 nights
- Warranty: 5 years
- Shipping: Free
The Layla topper is here to deliver all the benefits of copper-gel infused memory foam and add some plushness and luxury to your mattress.
Materials
This super-cozy foam mattress topper is made of a polyester-blend cover and 3 inches of dense, copper-gel infused foam (CertiPur-US certified). The materials are not only comfy but clean, as well—copper is naturally antimicrobial, and the cover is machine-washable.
Feel
Designed to make any sleeping surface feel like a cloud, the Layla topper can turn firm beds from a 7 to a 5 on the firmness scale (out of 10). What’s more, the gel in the memory foam gently contours to your curves while keeping your spine and body aligned for optimal support.
Cooling Features
The copper gel beads, which absorb heat and pull it away from the sleeper, and the ThermoGEL (a cooling agent) in the cover create what could possibly be the best cooling memory foam mattress topper ever made.
Compatibility
The Layla topper is compatible with any bed, and thanks to the straps on the corners securing it, it will stay in place no matter how much you or your partner tosses and turns.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 2 inches
- Certificates: CertiPur-US Certified
Pros
- + A cooler, cleaner, and more comfortable sleep
- + Multiple sales and discounts
- + Made in the US + 5-year warranty
Cons
- − Not suitable for those seeking a firm mattress topper
8. PlushBeds Natural Latex Topper
Best Latex Mattress Topper
- Type: Latex
- Trial period: NA
- Warranty: 5 years
- Shipping: Free
Want to know how latex feels, but you aren’t ready to splurge on a latex bed? Give this PlushBeds topper a try for all the benefits of natural latex, but at a much lower price.
Materials
This best-rated mattress topper is made of 100% natural Talalay, so it’s organic (certified by the strictest independent emissions standards), high-quality (no sagging, discoloration, or off-gassing), durable (it has a 20-year lifespan), and safe (it’s hypoallergenic and antimicrobial).
PlushBeds’ latex topper is available in two thickness options: 2 inches for a small touch of plushness and 3 inches for more cushioning, support, and pressure relief.
Feel
Named by external reviews as the best mattress topper for lower back pain, the PlushBeds Natural Latex Topper is comfy and soft, but responsive and elastic enough to relieve pressure and prevent sinkage. Plus, it’s available in four firmness options so it can meet the needs of any kind of sleeper.
Cooling Features
Not only is natural latex one of the best materials for cooling, but this topper also has an open-cell design for enhanced heat distribution.
Compatibility
Don’t have a mattress from PlushBeds? No problem! This latex mattress topper can go on any bed and can be securely placed under most fitted sheets.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 2 and 3 inches
- Certificates: GREENGUARD Gold, OEKO-TEX Standard 100, and Eco Institute
Pros
- + Seasonal sales & discounts
- + 20-year lifespan
- + Hypoallergenic, antimicrobial, and dust-mite resistant
Cons
- − No returns
9. Parachute Down Mattress Topper
Best Down Mattress Topper
- Type: Feather
- Trial period: 60 days
- Warranty: 3 years
- Shipping: Free
Do you want to feel like you’re sleeping on a “marshmallow-stuffed cloud”? Then the Parachute Down Topper, the best feather mattress topper we could find, is the one for you.
Materials
This light and fluffy topper is made of high-quality European white down and encased in a 100% sateen cotton shell for a truly luxurious feel. It features a dual-chamber design—i.e., there are two layers of down and feather for an even distribution. Meanwhile, the three-dimensional baffle box stitching further prevents the fill from shifting and avoids the formation of lumps.
Feel
One of the loftiest mattress toppers ever, this pad provides hugging comfort and cushioning but is supportive too. Sleepers feel swaddled, not like they’re sinking into the bed, meaning it’s super comfy and soft (like sleeping on the best pillow top mattress topper) but not great if you’re looking for added pressure relief.
Cooling Features
Down is one of the most temperature-responsive materials. It keeps hot sleepers cool, but it’s cozy and warm on winter nights.
Compatibility
This feather topper is the perfect match for all kinds of sleepers and beds.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, and King
- Thickness: 3 inches
- Certificates: Oeko-Tex certified
Pros
- + Ethically and sustainably sourced
- + Down alternative available
- + Sales and bundle deals
Cons
- − Dry-clean only
10. Saatva Graphite Mattress Topper
Best Mattress Topper for Back Pain
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: 45 days
- Warranty: 1 year
- Shipping: Free
Saatva mattress toppers are available in three materials: graphite-infused foam, which cools, supports, and is one of the best mattress toppers for back pain; latex, the most durable and priciest; and high-density foam, which offers plushness.
Materials
The Saatva Graphite Mattress Topper is made of three layers: a luxurious, 100% organic cotton cover that’s removable and easy to clean and maintain; graphite-infused memory foam, which conforms to the body, relieving pressure points; and a transitional layer of foam that evenly distributes weight for extra resilience and superior spinal support.
Feel
This topper has a medium-soft feel, but the two layers of high-density memory foam deliver contouring support and will stop your hips from sinking into the bed. This way, you’ll get the optimal level of spinal alignment—all the features a mattress topper for back pain should have.
Cooling Features
Graphite, a cooling agent that draws heat away from the body, complements the cover’s breathability and moisture-wicking properties for dry nights and a refreshing slumber.
Compatibility
Saatva mattress toppers are a snug fit on any mattress thanks to the four bands in the corners that securely strap the pad to the bed.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 3 inches
- Certificates: CertiPur-US Certified
Pros
- + Available in three different materials
- + Multiple sales and deals
- + Best foam mattress topper with dual-layer design
Cons
- − Short trial and warranty period
11. Dreamfoam 2" Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Best Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: 30 days
- Warranty: 30 days
- Shipping: Not free
The Dreamfoam is one of the most affordable on our list of the best mattress toppers.
Materials
The 2-inch thick gel-swirl memory foam in this topper is CertiPUR-US certified, so there are no chemicals, toxins, or off-gassing.
Feel
The Dreamfoam topper is incredibly comfortable, offering relief from pressure and fantastic body contouring that can make all your aches and pains disappear, users say.
The slow-responsive, dense foam is excellent for motion isolation as well, so couples can sleep undisturbed on this full-size mattress topper.
Cooling Features
The gel in the memory foam goes a long way toward boosting air circulation, dissipating heat, and letting you sleep cool all night.
Compatibility
The Dreamfoam topper can soften up any mattress—from old, worn-out beds to new, firmer models.
- Sizes: Twin, Full, Short Queen, Queen, King, and Cal King
- Thickness: 2 inches
- Certificates: CertiPUR-US certified
Pros
- + Made in the US, 100% safe
- + Flexible support + incredible comfort
- + Best foam mattress topper for under $100
Cons
- − Might be too soft for heavyweight users
12. Zinus Swirl Gel Cooling Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Best Egg Crate Mattress Topper
- Type: Memory foam
- Trial period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 5 years
- Shipping: Free
Zinus’ mattress toppers will make you and your mattress feel like new again, at a price suited to everyone’s budget (even a mattress topper for a full-sized bed costs less than $100).
Materials
This topper is made of swirl foam (CertiPUR-US certified for content, emissions, and durability), while the thickest option contains 1 inch of swirl memory foam and 3 inches of high-density foam.
The natural green tea and charcoal infusions keep the foam fresh and odor-free for an even more refreshing sleep.
Feel
Comfortable and rejuvenating, this topper is soft enough to give superb pressure relief, while the 3 inches of high-density foam in the bottom provide ample support for spinal alignment. With this in mind, it’s no surprise Zinus is one of the best mattress toppers for side sleepers.
Cooling Features
Thanks to the convoluted polyfoam (egg-crate design) and the specially formulated cooling gel, this topper provides enough airflow to dissipate heat and cool down even the hottest users.
Compatibility
This foam topper is intentionally designed to be smaller than the mattress to avoid users pulling or tearing it when getting on and off the bed.
- Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, and King
- Thickness: 1.5, 2, and 4 inches
- Certificates: CertiPUR-US
Pros
- + Ideal for shoppers on a budget
- + Available in three firmness options
- + Green tea for a relaxing smell
Cons
- − Not available in all standard mattress sizes
HOW WE SELECTED THE BEST MATTRESS TOPPER
Our Ranking Methodology
Did you know that there are over 170 bed-in-a-box mattress companies across the globe? And almost all of them manufacture toppers in addition to premium-quality beds and other sleep accessories.
With so much choice, shopping for a mattress topper can quickly become overwhelming and stressful.
We’re here to make the experience easier and more enjoyable!
Employing a strict set of criteria, we evaluated dozens of products and brands and rounded up the 12 best mattress toppers for 2021.
Here are the factors we considered when ranking the best of the best.
Comfort Is Number One
A mattress topper needs to be comfy above all else.
That’s why we tested all the mattress toppers on how much comfort they offered in terms of support, spinal alignment, and cushioning.
We especially considered cooling features since heat regulation plays a significant role in comfortable slumber. In our rankings, we gave higher marks to the best mattress toppers with high-quality temperature regulation features.
Quality of Materials
If comfort is the first consideration, the quality of the materials incorporated is next in line.
Our list only included brands with eco-friendly, durable, and safe materials that will give you the quality and comfort you deserve.
We looked at off-gassing as well. We eliminated the models that took more than a few days to air out, not to mention the ones that retained an unpleasant smell throughout our testing period.
Versatility and Variety
Is the mattress topper compatible with all beds, or does the company limit you to its own brand of mattresses?
Does it come in all mattress sizes, from a twin mattress topper to a Cal king? Are there any extra features that ensure the topper doesn’t shift or slide off the bed?
Does it give you the option to make your mattress firmer or softer, i.e., in how many firmness levels is it available?
There’s no one-size-fits-all for toppers, so more points go to the mattress manufacturers that offer a variety of options and thus more value for your money.
The Price Tag
Most good-quality mattress toppers range between $150 and $450, with a twin size coming in at around $199 and a solid-quality mattress topper for a queen bed selling for $400.
The ideal solution would be to stay somewhere in the middle, as mid-level brands usually give the most bang for your buck without compromising on quality.
All the models in our list are reasonably priced and offer an excellent quality-to-price ratio.
Company Policies
Free shipping and other discounts and savings opportunities are great bonuses, especially when buying pricier models (such as a king-size mattress topper sold for over $500). Still, the biggest perk is a lengthy trial and warranty period, giving users enough time to test out the topper and covering sleepers against any unforeseen issues or damage.
Brands that offer multiple discounts and deals—besides generous shipping, warranties, and return policies—went higher on the list.
Certificates
All the brands in our reviews of the best mattress toppers in 2021 have been certified by some of the most stringent third-party evaluation standards to ensure that the product you choose is 100% safe and free of chemicals and toxins.
What Are Users Saying?
The experiences of sleepers (both satisfied and unsatisfied) are among the best indicators of a mattress topper’s effectiveness and quality.
Accordingly, we gave more points to brands that received a larger number of positive reviews and were highly rated from the most popular mattress retailers.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW BEFORE BUYING A MATTRESS TOPPER
Buyer’s Guide
Ready to buy the best-rated mattress topper?
Here are a few things you need to know before you press the “Add to Cart” button.
Who Can Benefit From a Mattress Topper?
A mattress topper isn’t always a must, but there are certain situations where your sleeping experience can benefit immensely from purchasing a topper.
Do you have an older mattress?
Mattresses lose some of their support with time. Although a topper can’t magically restore your bed to what it was, or fix a saggy middle, the best mattress topper will go a long way toward improving your comfort. Plus, it will give you some wiggle room to choose a new mattress that ticks all your boxes, without the pressure of a rushed purchase or uncomfortable sleep.
A mattress topper will not only rejuvenate your aging bed, but it will also protect it from wear and tear, as well as dust mites and allergens.
Is your new bed too firm?
Your bed could be too firm or too soft for your preferences and needs, even if it’s brand new.
Depending on the type, a topper can significantly change the feel of your bed. For instance, a firm mattress topper can provide extra support where you need it the most, whereas a softer model will give the bed a more cushiony feel.
Do you sleep hot?
Even the most advanced cooling technology on a mattress can’t save hot sleepers from night sweats and restless sleep. However, a cooling mattress topper can help regulate temperature and make sure you sleep cool and comfy.
Do you and your partner have different sleep preferences?
Couples often have different sleeping styles. If splurging on a flippable mattress isn’t an option, why not give a mattress upgrade a try?
Buying a mattress topper in a twin or twin XL size will change the feel on only one side of the bed for the ultimate compromise.
Are you a student, or do you move around a lot?
Mattress toppers are easier to transport and store than beds. If you live in a dorm, tend to change addresses frequently, or live in a rented home, a topper is a much better investment than a new mattress.
Toppers are a great way to spruce up a cheaper spare-room mattress or fold-out sofa—giving your guests a more comfortable sleep.
Choosing Between a Mattress Pad vs. a Topper
A mattress topper sits on the top of your mattress (as the name suggests) to offer additional support or cushioning.
A mattress pad, on the other hand, is thinner. Although it provides some added comfort, it serves more to protect the bed from stains, spills, allergens, and other irritants.
Toppers are like mini-mattresses—they’re made of the same materials as beds, whereas pads are usually made from cotton or polyester. The materials’ quality determines their longevity and price, so a latex, foam, or wool mattress topper is typically more durable and more expensive than a pad.
Types of Mattress Toppers
Just like mattresses, mattress toppers come in a variety of types and materials. The most common materials for toppers include the following:
Memory Foam
This is one of the most popular materials for mattresses and toppers alike.
A memory foam mattress topper is soft and comfy, letting you sink into your bed and giving you that cloud-like sleep sensation. It’s the ideal choice for people who want more cushioning from their firm mattresses and those who have an older, less supportive bed.
Since memory foam hugs the body, these mattress toppers can sometimes make users feel like they’re sinking too far into the bed, primarily heavyweight and stomach sleepers.
Still, the biggest downside to memory foam toppers is the heat. This material is notorious for trapping heat, so it’s not the best option for hot sleepers.
If you tend to overheat during the night but still want the cradling feeling of memory foam, try a cooling gel-infused topper. The best gel memory foam mattress topper will help wick away heat and moisture, keeping you fresh and dry while you sleep.
Latex
Natural latex, one of the most durable and supportive materials, is an excellent choice for people who need extra firmness, especially those who have arthritis or painful joints.
A natural latex mattress topper is bouncy as well. However, it doesn’t transfer motion, so you can sleep undisturbed.
Natural latex is antimicrobial and non-allergenic—a great choice for eco-conscious shoppers and those with allergies.
There are downsides, though, even with the best latex mattress toppers. Latex is costly and quite heavy. Plus, it isn’t the right choice for people looking for a softer mattress or those allergic to the material.
Fiber Fill
The cheapest, but least supportive alternative, fiber-filled (or down-alternative) toppers are filled with a polyester blend or some other synthetic fiber.
These toppers are soft and fluffy—the ideal option if you want to add extra plushness to a firmer mattress. Most of them can be machine-washed too, making maintenance a piece of cake.
However, these aren’t the best mattress toppers for back pain as they tend to squash down and quickly lose their volume, leaving the sleeper with no support or cushioning.
If you’re in the process of buying a new mattress and need additional padding in the meantime, fiber-filled toppers could be an inexpensive, but temporary solution.
Feather
Feather mattress toppers are luxurious and soft.
A down mattress topper gives more cushioning than latex and allows for easier movement than memory foam, but there are drawbacks.
First, these toppers don’t do much in terms of support. On top of that, they need more maintenance—down toppers can only be spot-cleaned, and users will need to fluff and shake them often to avoid lumps from forming.
Feather toppers are crunchier (feather can poke through the cover) and tend to compress over time, losing their plushness.
Wool
Wool toppers are the most expensive, but worth every cent, especially if you’re looking for temperature regulation. Wool is exceptionally breathable, so it’s guaranteed to keep you fresh at night. It’s one of the easiest materials to maintain, too.
Nevertheless, a wool mattress topper doesn’t offer a lot of support, and it won’t conform to your body like memory foam.
Convoluted Polyfoam (or “Egg Crate”)
This type of topper is made of polyfoam with a ridged surface, i.e., a “peaks and valleys” design.
It contours nicely to the body so that there’s minimal motion transfer, although not as much as memory foam. It isn’t as hot as memory foam, either, as the breathable design allows for more airflow.
Even though it’s cheaper, an egg crate mattress topper isn’t very durable and isn’t as effective as solid foam upgrades when it comes to support.
In short, it would be the perfect choice for someone who wants a softer mattress while operating with a tight budget.
What to Consider Before Buying a Mattress Topper
These are some of the most important factors to consider when buying a mattress topper:
Firmness
If your mattress is too soft, adding the best firm mattress topper can give you more support and pressure relief around your hips, shoulders, and joints. If the mattress is too firm, a softer topper—like wool, feather, or fiber fill—is the way to go.
Firmness, however, is relative and depends on your sleeping position and weight. Thus, lightweight side sleepers should consider a soft to medium-soft topper, while heavier side sleepers will need a medium-firm to firm topper for less sinkage.
A medium-firm topper is the best option for back sleepers and stomach sleepers. However, it may not be right for heavier stomach sleepers, who often need an extra-firm mattress topper.
Thickness
Toppers are typically 1–4 inches thick.
Heavyweight and side sleepers would probably prefer a thicker option (3–4 inches) as this offers more pressure relief. In comparison, a thinner model (1–2 inches) would be a better choice for users looking for a minor upgrade.
Cooling Features
If you’re a hot sleeper or have a mattress known for trapping heat, you should look for a pad that provides heat regulation, such as a gel memory foam mattress topper or one with a breathable fabric cover.
Product Care
Most mattress toppers aren’t washer-friendly and have to be dry-cleaned instead. Some, though, come with a removable cover, making maintenance less of a hassle.
If the mattress tends to get stained—for instance, if kids are using it—you might want to look for a topper you can wash in the machine or invest in a mattress protector that will shield both the topper and your bed from spills and damage.
Size
A good bed upgrade needs to be the right size, i.e., if you have a queen mattress, you’ll need a queen mattress topper. The good news: mattress toppers come in the same sizes as beds, so finding the right size isn’t that hard.
Another factor to think about: make sure that the mattress topper fits under your bedding, such as a fitted sheet, for a snug fit.
Materials
Different materials provide different feels. As noted above in our best mattress topper review, latex will give your bed more firmness and bounce, while a fiber-filled or foam topper offers plushness and extra cushioning.
The material you choose will determine the durability too. For example, latex, memory foam, and wool toppers have a longer lifespan and show fewer signs of excessive sagging or indentation over time.
Certifications
Different certifications apply depending on the materials used. Just make sure that the certification your topper carries guarantees that its materials are safe and free of harmful chemicals.
Allergies
Some materials, such as latex and feathers, can trigger allergies in users. Sleepers with sensitivities will be better off with hypoallergenic toppers like fiber or wool.
Price
Toppers can be pricey (a mattress topper for a king bed could be as high as $500 or more). They’re made of the same high-quality materials that go into beds, and they’re created to provide even more comfort, hence the high price tag.
Still, the cost shouldn’t discourage you.
Don’t go for the cheapest option as it’s most likely of the lowest quality. Instead, look for brands that have a generous warranty policy. A lengthy sleep trial is another thing to consider. Not only does it give you time to test out the product, but it also inspires trust in the company.
Motion Isolation
If you have a partner who tosses and turns in their sleep or you sleep with your pet, it’s essential to choose an upgrade with superior motion isolation, like the best latex or best-rated memory foam mattress topper.
Note, though, that memory foam toppers aren’t ideal for sex, whereas all other types of upgrades (latex in particular) are more than responsive.
Wrapping It Up
People often underestimate the power of a good mattress topper.
A high-quality upgrade is an easy, quick, and affordable way to transform an old, lumpy, or hot mattress into a comfy and supportive haven. So if you’re looking to change the feel of your mattress without having to change your bed, mattress toppers are among the best sleep accessories you can buy.
We hope that our best mattress topper reviews and buyer’s guide have armed you with all the information you need to buy the perfect mattress upgrade for your needs and get the good night’s rest you deserve.
FAQs
What is a mattress topper?
As the name suggests, a mattress topper is an extra layer of material placed on top of your bed to add support or cushioning—i.e., make your bed firmer or softer. Mattress toppers can also help you sleep cooler through the night.
Toppers are generally easier to clean and definitely more affordable than changing your whole mattress, plus they add another layer of protection from spills and stains.
What thickness mattress topper should I get?
This depends on personal preference, but basically, the thicker the topper, the more cushioning you’ll get. Thus, a 2-inch thick topper would be ideal for more support and firmness, while a thicker topper would be an excellent choice for a luxurious feel.
If you want to spruce up an older, worn-out mattress, you can try a 3-inch topper, although these might add some height to your mattress and make jumping out of bed harder in the morning.
What is the best mattress topper?
The best topper for you depends on what you’re looking for. So the first step is to determine your requirements: Do you want relief for back pain? Something to make the spare room’s bed cozier? What about extra plushness?
Our list of the best is here to help you in the process—you won’t have buyer’s regret with any of the models in our rankings.
Which mattress topper is best for back pain?
Memory foam and latex are usually the most popular choices for those suffering from lower back pain as they conform evenly to the body, providing enough support in the lumbar area and cushioning in the hips and shoulders. This way, the spine falls into a neutral alignment, improving sleep quality and relieving back pain.
What is the best thickness for a memory foam mattress topper?
Most memory foam mattresses come in various thickness options—usually 1–4 inches thick. Even though the right thickness depends on your body shape, sleep style, and requirements, a good foam mattress should be at least 2 inches thick to be effective.
Do mattress toppers really work?
Yes, they do! The best mattress toppers will add a couple of years to your existing bed, provide a more comfortable and restful sleep by providing more cushioning, support, or coolness (depending on your needs), and protect your bed from physical damages and allergens to boot.
